As the year comes to an end, it is time to reflect on the past season. Last week a few TV critics from The New York Times chimed in with their favorites. And while the lists were similar in many ways, a few entries stood out. For instance, Mike Hale placed PBS's Moyers & Company among the top 10, noting:
Conservative politicians campaigning against PBS shouldn’t focus just on
tax dollars: the network is also home to the most subversive show on
American television. Sitting at a small desk on a bare set, Bill Moyers
asks scholars, journalists and activists questions about our political
system — whom it serves, how it’s paid for — that no one else is asking
on screen.
And Alessandra Stanley's list includes the Presidential election:
Normally epic on-air meltdowns happen on reality shows or during an Oscar
acceptance speech, but this year the most memorable live moments were
prompted by the presidential campaign. The best came on election night
on Fox News, when the channel’s Republican expert Karl Rove had a
tantrum, rejecting his network’s own figures, and sulkily refused to
accept that despite all his predictions, and “super PAC” spending, the
winner was Barack Obama.
I would add the Republican debates to this list if you were strictly rating comedies (or is it farce?).
June Thomas in Slate has her own top 15 picks, with a few surprises including C-SPAN2's Book TV:
A DVR malfunction can
reveal a lot about your true feelings for a show. When you feel bereft
to learn that a show hasn’t recorded, you’re saying that some part of
you finds it essential. Book TV—a
parade of author readings, Q&As, and live feeds from book festivals
from around the nation—speaks through the electronic program guide.
Every few weeks I curse the TV gods when my Friday night cruise through
the listings to find out which authors Book TV will be serving
up this weekend comes up empty—offering vague listings rather than
specifying which new books will be featured. That’s how I know Book TV is an indispensable part of my weekend.
I am still compiling my list, but it's fun to see what others are watching.